Scimitar Shoes Reviews
What our customers say matters. Here you can read honest feedback about fit, comfort, quality and durability from people who wear Scimitar Shoes every day. We do not edit or cherry-pick reviews; we aim to give you a clear picture so you can decide if our footwear is right for you.
What Customers Say
"The comfort is outstanding and they look smart enough for the office. I've had my Scimitar brogues for two years and they're still going strong. Proper British quality."
James T.
Verified Customer
"Finally found ankle boots that don't rub. Wore them straight out of the box for a full day. Delivery was quick and packaging was proper—no squashed boxes."
Sarah M.
Verified Customer
"I was sceptical about buying shoes online but the size guide was spot on. My loafers fit perfectly and the leather is lovely. Will definitely order again."
David K.
Verified Customer
"Great value for British-made shoes. The leather has aged nicely and they're still comfortable after a year of regular wear. Customer service was helpful when I had a sizing question."
Emma R.
Verified Customer
Why We Share Reviews
Buying shoes online can feel like a gamble. You cannot try them on first, and photos do not always tell you how a pair will feel after a full day. That is why we put customer reviews front and centre. We want you to hear from people who have already worn Scimitar Shoes: whether the fit was true to size, how quickly they broke in, and whether they would buy again.
We do not pay for five-star reviews or hide negative feedback. Of course we hope you will be happy, but we also know that honest reviews help you choose the right style and size. If something goes wrong—wrong size, defect, or simply not what you expected—we encourage you to contact us. Our aim is to put it right and, where relevant, to improve our products and service based on what you tell us.
What Customers Mention Most
In our experience, customers often comment on a few things. Comfort is a recurring theme: many say their Scimitar Shoes were comfortable from the first wear, or after a short break-in. Fit is another: we work hard on our size guides and last shapes, and feedback suggests that when customers follow the guide, they usually get a good fit. Quality of materials and finish are also mentioned—people notice good leather and neat stitching. Lastly, durability: customers who have had their shoes for a year or more often report that they are holding up well with basic care.
How We Use Your Feedback
Every review and every piece of customer feedback is read. We use it to refine our range: adjusting lasts where we see consistent comments about width or length, improving linings or footbeds where comfort is mentioned, and updating product descriptions so that what you read matches what you get. If you have already bought from us, thank you—and if you are happy to leave a review, it really does help others make an informed choice. If you have not tried us yet, we hope the reviews on this page give you a clearer picture of what to expect from Scimitar Shoes.
To learn more about how and where we make our shoes, visit our Where Made page. For any questions about sizing, delivery or returns, get in touch—we are here to help.
See Where We're Made
Discover the British craftsmanship behind every pair of Scimitar Shoes.
Where Made